I talk regularly about how I think that kids must, and I mean MUST, write in the math class. It's a lot of work for you as a teacher because you need to give time to do something lengthy, and then give some time for them to start the write-ups during class, then you need to give them copious written feedback on the first draft, and then maybe have a discussion with the whole class about how to organize their ideas logically, and then you need to still read every kid's final draft and to assign them grades, and then to post a task-specific rubric. In the end, this process is so SO worth it, even if some of the kids' products are not stellar. The important thing is that when they write, they are really learning about what it takes to put their mathematical thoughts down in words in a way that makes sense to another person outside of our class, and they're forced to re-evaluate how well they themselves understand each step. Moreover, if they are asked to make a draft and then a heavily revised draft, they begin to invest in the quality of their work and to learn to take pride in their work -- no matter how much help they might have needed along the way.
Here and here are two lab write-ups from earlier this semester (maybe November), when the kids wrote about the process of stacking cups to match a classmate's height. The two kids I posted are just two random kid athletes who happened to send me their files before they went away on a sports trip, so they definitely weren't the most polished pieces from the class, but they ARE a realistic look at what "regular" 8th-graders can do with a bit of support. (These have some errors in them, of course, but I decided to just post them as is. The kids who had really top-notch, exemplary projects didn't submit digitally, and I haven't bothered to scan them.)
I also have some interesting samples of the percent/shopping projects and the three-variable projects that my 7th- and 8th-graders worked on at the end of Semester 1, leading into Semester 2. I'll post those in a few days if you check back then. They've turned in their "first drafts", which they think are polished (last graded assignment of Semester 1), but look fairly hairy to me still, and now they'll get a chance to polish those drafts based on my written feedback, for the next round of submissions (counted as part of Semester 2).
Hope this makes you excited about writing in the math class! I love projects and I love making kids write about math. For me, I think all worthwhile math projects are inherently interdisciplinary, because even if you're teaching strictly math, as soon as the kids are asked to communicate, reflect, present, create... then you're already bringing in essential skills that they develop from other classes and helping them see that other subject skills do not stop at the classroom door. After all, we are full-time educators as much as we are math teachers. :)
PS. I have to admit that sometimes, grading the first math writing assignments of the year makes me very aggravated, because most of the kids have never done such math tasks before my class. They don't know how or when to use diagrams to visualize; they jump straight into math discussions without any introduction; they either write a lot of symbols without attaching any description OR they just give numerical results without showing the work on how they got those values; they keep repeating themselves because they cannot organize their thoughts in an efficient manner; and they seem to have developed some secret language that doesn't make sense to anyone outside of the class but me, in describing their mathematical process. But, THAT IS EVEN MORE REASON for them to write!!! By the time they leave my class, I would say that the majority of students can piece together a fairly coherent discussion of a relatively straight-forward math topic, without too much help on my part.
I just wanted to put this out there in case you are wondering, "Is it just my students who are so bad with mathematical writing?!" The answer is No. Usually I have to eat a lot of chocolate and to take lots of rest breaks when I grade the first writing assignment "rough drafts" of the year.
Sunday, January 20, 2013
Friday, January 18, 2013
Big Life Change.........?
Since I've talked to my admin, now it's OK for me to say it to you guys: I will probably have to move at the end of this school year, sadly.
I love LOVE my current school. I will be sad to move. But, a potentially great opportunity has come up for Geoff, and for that we would have to relocate back to the U.S. It is something that I couldn't ask him to give up, so I decided that I loved him more than enough to give up what I have here and to take a leap of faith. So, I told my school this week that although I am still waiting for more clarity on his part to fully decide, I wanted to let them know of this probability of leaving, so that if they felt the need to immediately start looking for a teacher, they could do that and not lose out on the chance to interview quality math teachers. I was very nervous before telling them, because I didn't know whether they would understand my priorities and whether they would be supportive. To my relief, they were super understanding. They said they will wait for my final decision before looking for a replacement, because they'd much rather keep me than to hire "anyone else." Awwwwwwww.... That is so-so-sooooo sweet, but it also makes it hard to really come to a happy, final decision. (I almost would rather them say that they will start looking tomorrow for a replacement, so that I'd be forced to find a job.) Anyhow, so I decided that I'll be looking in Seattle for a teaching post during my February visit, and either I'll find a job that I'm excited about, which'll firm up my decision to move, or I'll see/visit schools that may not be immediately hiring but are promising opportunities, which'll also help to make my decision to move, or -- if nothing looks right and Geoff's job situation is still muddy -- we could decide to stay in Berlin. We will then let my school know, immediately following our February break, so that they can start interviewing if they need to. And, they're totally OK with that timeline! (I have the best admin, seriously. They've always been incredibly supportive of me, in things big and small.)
So, although I am very sad about potentially/"probably" leaving my school and my job as department chair (I was really just starting to feel like what I do makes a difference to the teachers), I have to ask you to keep your ears open for possible openings in the Seattle area. I promise you that I'm great to work with, even though you guys have never met me. Here is my CV, and a cover letter as well. Let me know if you know someone who knows someone who knows someone in Seattle... Help a sista out!! xoxo.
I love LOVE my current school. I will be sad to move. But, a potentially great opportunity has come up for Geoff, and for that we would have to relocate back to the U.S. It is something that I couldn't ask him to give up, so I decided that I loved him more than enough to give up what I have here and to take a leap of faith. So, I told my school this week that although I am still waiting for more clarity on his part to fully decide, I wanted to let them know of this probability of leaving, so that if they felt the need to immediately start looking for a teacher, they could do that and not lose out on the chance to interview quality math teachers. I was very nervous before telling them, because I didn't know whether they would understand my priorities and whether they would be supportive. To my relief, they were super understanding. They said they will wait for my final decision before looking for a replacement, because they'd much rather keep me than to hire "anyone else." Awwwwwwww.... That is so-so-sooooo sweet, but it also makes it hard to really come to a happy, final decision. (I almost would rather them say that they will start looking tomorrow for a replacement, so that I'd be forced to find a job.) Anyhow, so I decided that I'll be looking in Seattle for a teaching post during my February visit, and either I'll find a job that I'm excited about, which'll firm up my decision to move, or I'll see/visit schools that may not be immediately hiring but are promising opportunities, which'll also help to make my decision to move, or -- if nothing looks right and Geoff's job situation is still muddy -- we could decide to stay in Berlin. We will then let my school know, immediately following our February break, so that they can start interviewing if they need to. And, they're totally OK with that timeline! (I have the best admin, seriously. They've always been incredibly supportive of me, in things big and small.)
So, although I am very sad about potentially/"probably" leaving my school and my job as department chair (I was really just starting to feel like what I do makes a difference to the teachers), I have to ask you to keep your ears open for possible openings in the Seattle area. I promise you that I'm great to work with, even though you guys have never met me. Here is my CV, and a cover letter as well. Let me know if you know someone who knows someone who knows someone in Seattle... Help a sista out!! xoxo.
Thursday, January 17, 2013
Request for Resources on Benefits of Technology
Hi everyone,
I am searching currently for any resources (printed or web) that you can point me at, that discuss the benefits of graphing calculator-based learning of mathematics. Within our department there are some differing opinions about this (since some teachers are still quite traditional), and so a colleague has asked me for more resources so that they can further analyze this issue. I thought I'd ask you guys, who are the experts, to see if you had such resources handy. Personally, I feel that technological approaches in general can help students visualize math in a way that helps them to understand connections between graphs and algebra, which was not possible a generation ago for the kids who lacked fluent graphing skills. It also serves as a motivation, as you can already see the desired end result and you're just working towards understanding the process to getting that end value. It also helps with problem-solving, in bypassing the hump of algebra, since in the "real world" they may not remember how to crank through every problem manually but they'll still need the analytical skills to be able to evaluate a graph and what it means. BUT, that's all just what I think. What "official" resources or studies do you have that can corroborate this?
THANK YOU!
I am searching currently for any resources (printed or web) that you can point me at, that discuss the benefits of graphing calculator-based learning of mathematics. Within our department there are some differing opinions about this (since some teachers are still quite traditional), and so a colleague has asked me for more resources so that they can further analyze this issue. I thought I'd ask you guys, who are the experts, to see if you had such resources handy. Personally, I feel that technological approaches in general can help students visualize math in a way that helps them to understand connections between graphs and algebra, which was not possible a generation ago for the kids who lacked fluent graphing skills. It also serves as a motivation, as you can already see the desired end result and you're just working towards understanding the process to getting that end value. It also helps with problem-solving, in bypassing the hump of algebra, since in the "real world" they may not remember how to crank through every problem manually but they'll still need the analytical skills to be able to evaluate a graph and what it means. BUT, that's all just what I think. What "official" resources or studies do you have that can corroborate this?
THANK YOU!
Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Visual pattern of 3 variables
Since I have multi-input relationships on my mind, here is a visual pattern of 3 variables for you to enjoy (row, column, result). I've submitted this to the good folks at visualpatterns.org, but because of the nature of the complexity of this problem, I'm not quite sure that it quite fits well with everything else over there. Anyhow, it's a good problem for your abstract thinkers and ties in the concept of both arithmetic and geometric sequences quite nicely, I think.
Above shows rows 1, 2, 3 starting at the top. It also shows columns 1, 2, 3, 4 starting from the left to the right. At this rate, in row 8, column 10, there will be 23040 cubes. Can you find out how many cubes there will be for row 20, column 15?
Above shows rows 1, 2, 3 starting at the top. It also shows columns 1, 2, 3, 4 starting from the left to the right. At this rate, in row 8, column 10, there will be 23040 cubes. Can you find out how many cubes there will be for row 20, column 15?
Saturday, January 12, 2013
Wedding Excitement
OMG, I get married in less than 90 days, and I cannot wait! The dress fiasco got fixed, eventually, by my wonderful seamstress. I think altogether we had about 5 or 6 fittings, but it was totally worth it because in the end, the finished product was unique and very appropriate for a beach wedding! (I took a dress on the rack that I had liked but that was a lot of sizes too big, essentially had them take it apart and remake the dress to fit me, and then they had to create fabric to simulate the dress in order to alter its style, and then I had a whole other part made to be added to the dress.) During the entire process, my seamstress was wonderfully patient, and in the end she almost didn't accept my extra tips for her!! (She said, "That is my job!") If you live in Berlin and you're thinking about shopping for a wedding dress, and you think you might want something altered and not directly off the rack, I highly recommend Crusz, the abendkleid and brautkleid shop near Spittelmarkt. You will be very happy with Alex, their on-site seamstress!
And then today I went accessories shopping. I needed shoes, some hair decoration, and a necklace. I decided to head to Charlottenburg, because that area of town is relatively nearby (it was snowing hard today) and also it's pretty posh, which means that it has the potential to have nice accessories. In the end, I bought a very simple single-pearl necklace (for me, since I don't have very sharp facial features, sometimes simpler is better because then it does not overwhelm my look) en route to one of the shops, Felicita, which I had found online. When I arrived at Felicita, I noticed right away that 1. They have vintage-inspired dresses and accessories, which is awesome because I dance swing so I like vintage things, 2. The shop-owner looks familiar. I think I had been there before when I dress-shopped, but the dresses they showed me didn't quite have the "wow" factor for my face/body type. (They looked beautiful and vintage and romantic on the rack today, so I'm pretty sure it's just a misfit for my style.) Anyway, I wasn't sure what I wanted to find there, but I had brought along a fabric sample from my dress, so I showed it to them, as well as a picture of my dress (which they said is a very "modern" style... I think they were surprised by it), and they let me try on a few hair accessories that they thought would work well with the dress. (Because it was "modern", they had immediately rejected the idea of a veil. Good thing, since I had already rejected having a veil based on the possibility of a very windy day on the beach.) And, they were right! The first hair thing that they brought me was not something I would have picked out for myself, but I absolutely loved how it looked on me/how it complemented my necklace, and immediately I could picture it going well with my dress as well. They ended up showing me a few others, but that first hair accessory was still my favorite, so I did not hesitate to buy it.
Then I tried on some shoes there, and they had some nice, simple, comfortable, and even vintage-inspired shoes. But in the end I didn't feel confident making a choice without trying the shoes on with my dress, so we agreed that the next weekend I'll go back, bring my dress along, and give it another shot. Hopefully I'll get something then, so that this won't be a "thing" hanging over my head as we move into February...
--But, in any case, I am still miles ahead of Geoff, who hasn't even started to think about what he's going to wear at our wedding! I am not really worried though. I had looked through the wedding photos of our wedding planner's past events, and most of the guys dress very casually, and they still look good on the beach! I'm not stressed. I think Geoff can wear khakis and a hippie shirt, and he'd probably still be fine.
Anyway, now that my attire is slowly coming together, I am very excited about the wedding!! We have about 50 guests, I estimate. The girl at the shop mentioned that this is like a dream wedding, and it is!! I am starting to get totally excited about my wedding, even though I had never thought about weddings until about a year and a half ago.(I'm not one of those people who dreamed always of weddings. Actually, Geoff and I aren't even having a wedding party, just to keep things simple. We would have been very happy to get married even with just our parents there! Having 50 guests, many of whom are staying at the same resort as us, is like a dream. And since I'm going to ask ALL the girls to wear flowers in their hair, it's going to be very festive and lovely all around, and it'll also help everyone feel extra lovely!)
So, yeah, this is probably my last wedding update before the wedding. (I hope.) I'm going to take this opportunity to say that it's a non-zero possibility that there will be math puzzles at my wedding, since Geoff was pretty enthusiastic about the idea. I think it's "only right" that everyone completes a puzzle before they can get their first drink, and it'll also help people mingle to help each other. :)
And then today I went accessories shopping. I needed shoes, some hair decoration, and a necklace. I decided to head to Charlottenburg, because that area of town is relatively nearby (it was snowing hard today) and also it's pretty posh, which means that it has the potential to have nice accessories. In the end, I bought a very simple single-pearl necklace (for me, since I don't have very sharp facial features, sometimes simpler is better because then it does not overwhelm my look) en route to one of the shops, Felicita, which I had found online. When I arrived at Felicita, I noticed right away that 1. They have vintage-inspired dresses and accessories, which is awesome because I dance swing so I like vintage things, 2. The shop-owner looks familiar. I think I had been there before when I dress-shopped, but the dresses they showed me didn't quite have the "wow" factor for my face/body type. (They looked beautiful and vintage and romantic on the rack today, so I'm pretty sure it's just a misfit for my style.) Anyway, I wasn't sure what I wanted to find there, but I had brought along a fabric sample from my dress, so I showed it to them, as well as a picture of my dress (which they said is a very "modern" style... I think they were surprised by it), and they let me try on a few hair accessories that they thought would work well with the dress. (Because it was "modern", they had immediately rejected the idea of a veil. Good thing, since I had already rejected having a veil based on the possibility of a very windy day on the beach.) And, they were right! The first hair thing that they brought me was not something I would have picked out for myself, but I absolutely loved how it looked on me/how it complemented my necklace, and immediately I could picture it going well with my dress as well. They ended up showing me a few others, but that first hair accessory was still my favorite, so I did not hesitate to buy it.
Then I tried on some shoes there, and they had some nice, simple, comfortable, and even vintage-inspired shoes. But in the end I didn't feel confident making a choice without trying the shoes on with my dress, so we agreed that the next weekend I'll go back, bring my dress along, and give it another shot. Hopefully I'll get something then, so that this won't be a "thing" hanging over my head as we move into February...
--But, in any case, I am still miles ahead of Geoff, who hasn't even started to think about what he's going to wear at our wedding! I am not really worried though. I had looked through the wedding photos of our wedding planner's past events, and most of the guys dress very casually, and they still look good on the beach! I'm not stressed. I think Geoff can wear khakis and a hippie shirt, and he'd probably still be fine.
Anyway, now that my attire is slowly coming together, I am very excited about the wedding!! We have about 50 guests, I estimate. The girl at the shop mentioned that this is like a dream wedding, and it is!! I am starting to get totally excited about my wedding, even though I had never thought about weddings until about a year and a half ago.(I'm not one of those people who dreamed always of weddings. Actually, Geoff and I aren't even having a wedding party, just to keep things simple. We would have been very happy to get married even with just our parents there! Having 50 guests, many of whom are staying at the same resort as us, is like a dream. And since I'm going to ask ALL the girls to wear flowers in their hair, it's going to be very festive and lovely all around, and it'll also help everyone feel extra lovely!)
So, yeah, this is probably my last wedding update before the wedding. (I hope.) I'm going to take this opportunity to say that it's a non-zero possibility that there will be math puzzles at my wedding, since Geoff was pretty enthusiastic about the idea. I think it's "only right" that everyone completes a puzzle before they can get their first drink, and it'll also help people mingle to help each other. :)
Friday, January 11, 2013
Grade 7 Project: Percents and Shopping
Speaking of projects, I recently had a very lovely experience collaborating off of my colleague's percents project. I took an old project that she had written up and added extra components to it, and then gave the feedback back to her so that in the future she might incorporate the new elements. I really loved this iterative process, and she was happy as well!
Here was her original project.
Here was my add-on.
Essentially, I took the same percentage discount elements (my kids are still calculating percents by dividing by 10 to get 10%, and then working through proportional reasoning) and then added a creative component, where percent increase (shipping fee) was incorporated into this project by asking the students to come up with their own online shopping story. I also would only check the first two steps (1A and 1B) of the project, plus the calculations for their individual creative piece. The rest of the project had to be checked some other way, so they had to brainstorm ways to check their work -- and they'll be graded on this "reflective" process in addition to their overall explanations, clarity of thought/work, and accuracy.
In the end, the kids helped each other to identify a variety of math concepts (decimals, rounding, percentage, addition vs. subtraction, sequential application of percentage change, checking your work using inverse operations) that were required in this project. I'm still waiting for their writeup, to be due next week, and then probably a revised version (depending on how well the drafts are done the first time). I'm quite happy about how it has gone thus far!
These same 7th-graders also rocked their algebra, fractions, and basic percents on the first semester test. They had come in to my class not knowing integers, order of operations, or how to calculate even simple fractions. I'm so proud that they ended up doing better on the semester exam than my previous students did a year ago!!! WAY TO GO, GRADE 7. Rocking my world, one day at a time.
Here was her original project.
Here was my add-on.
Essentially, I took the same percentage discount elements (my kids are still calculating percents by dividing by 10 to get 10%, and then working through proportional reasoning) and then added a creative component, where percent increase (shipping fee) was incorporated into this project by asking the students to come up with their own online shopping story. I also would only check the first two steps (1A and 1B) of the project, plus the calculations for their individual creative piece. The rest of the project had to be checked some other way, so they had to brainstorm ways to check their work -- and they'll be graded on this "reflective" process in addition to their overall explanations, clarity of thought/work, and accuracy.
In the end, the kids helped each other to identify a variety of math concepts (decimals, rounding, percentage, addition vs. subtraction, sequential application of percentage change, checking your work using inverse operations) that were required in this project. I'm still waiting for their writeup, to be due next week, and then probably a revised version (depending on how well the drafts are done the first time). I'm quite happy about how it has gone thus far!
These same 7th-graders also rocked their algebra, fractions, and basic percents on the first semester test. They had come in to my class not knowing integers, order of operations, or how to calculate even simple fractions. I'm so proud that they ended up doing better on the semester exam than my previous students did a year ago!!! WAY TO GO, GRADE 7. Rocking my world, one day at a time.
3-Variable Project Success!
This is a follow up to my three-variable project in Grade 8, which we're finally doing now that the semester test is out of the way. The kids are really enjoying it, and it helps to solidify the idea that multiple variables can cause the numerical output to change. (I tied this in our introductory discussion to familiar formulas like A=lw and P=2l + 2w). Prior to starting the project, I also quickly pulled up a real-world 3-variable table and asked them to tell me where the causes are and where the effects are, inside this format of the stockings sizing chart. This really helped them to understand and relate to the table setup on their given project sheet, in terms of visualizing why the table is set up that way.
They worked through the first table with guidance, and found the general formula pretty easily once I asked them "if n = 100, what is the formula for y? What if n = 372? What if n is just any n?" After this, they repeated the process for the second (and for some students, as well the third) table of values. The last two days we worked on verifying the general formulas they found, first manually -- learning to show proper work for multiple math test cases -- then with technology.
It took me a little bit to figure out how to set this up, but I made this http://bit.ly/excelTestTemplate to help my 8th-graders test their general formulas for their projects. I am very excited to see the outcome of this project, because as part of the testing procedure I also taught them how to program a very basic loop in the graphing calculator, in order to prompt for two variables, perform a basic formula, and then output the results. It looks like this for testing the first formula y = mn + n.
:While 1
:Prompt M
:Prompt N
:Disp M*N + N
:End
The kids took about 30 minutes today programming their graphing calcs to run their general formulas, testing them with a few entries from the table, and documenting it all using their camera phones in order to insert it into the math reports that they will be working all of next week. SWEETNESS. This'll be their second time writing a formal Grade 8 math paper for me, and since the first ones were pretty decent, I think this round will be as well.
I also made this project writeup guidelines to help them with framing their writeup. We discussed at various points of this project, how this mathematical process is very similar to the scientific process, with looking at the effect of a single variable at a time, then combining results to form a general hypothesis (ie. the general formula involving all variables), then test-test-testing your hypothesis using a variety of test cases and test methods. What a perfect age group to do this with, since their little minds are just opening up to the world of thinking logically and sequentially and doubting everything.
I hope you have a break in between heavy-duty algebra topics to do this with your kids. Highly recommended! Super duper multi-faceted project involving a variety of skills.
Addendum: My colleague recommended to me that at the end of the project, I show the kids the 3-D graph using x, y, z as the variables. Wow, that's pretty crazy. I don't know if they're quite ready to handle this!
They worked through the first table with guidance, and found the general formula pretty easily once I asked them "if n = 100, what is the formula for y? What if n = 372? What if n is just any n?" After this, they repeated the process for the second (and for some students, as well the third) table of values. The last two days we worked on verifying the general formulas they found, first manually -- learning to show proper work for multiple math test cases -- then with technology.
It took me a little bit to figure out how to set this up, but I made this http://bit.ly/excelTestTemplate to help my 8th-graders test their general formulas for their projects. I am very excited to see the outcome of this project, because as part of the testing procedure I also taught them how to program a very basic loop in the graphing calculator, in order to prompt for two variables, perform a basic formula, and then output the results. It looks like this for testing the first formula y = mn + n.
:While 1
:Prompt M
:Prompt N
:Disp M*N + N
:End
The kids took about 30 minutes today programming their graphing calcs to run their general formulas, testing them with a few entries from the table, and documenting it all using their camera phones in order to insert it into the math reports that they will be working all of next week. SWEETNESS. This'll be their second time writing a formal Grade 8 math paper for me, and since the first ones were pretty decent, I think this round will be as well.
I also made this project writeup guidelines to help them with framing their writeup. We discussed at various points of this project, how this mathematical process is very similar to the scientific process, with looking at the effect of a single variable at a time, then combining results to form a general hypothesis (ie. the general formula involving all variables), then test-test-testing your hypothesis using a variety of test cases and test methods. What a perfect age group to do this with, since their little minds are just opening up to the world of thinking logically and sequentially and doubting everything.
I hope you have a break in between heavy-duty algebra topics to do this with your kids. Highly recommended! Super duper multi-faceted project involving a variety of skills.
Addendum: My colleague recommended to me that at the end of the project, I show the kids the 3-D graph using x, y, z as the variables. Wow, that's pretty crazy. I don't know if they're quite ready to handle this!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)