I am reading parts of John Hattie's Visible Learning for Teachers, which has some real gems. Since this book reads dense like a textbook, I find that it is the most enticing when I flip through and just randomly stumble upon sections that are appealing to my wandering mind.
One part of the book talks about what successful feedback looks like.
The criteria for evaluating any learning achievements must be made transparent to students to enable them to have a clear overview of the aims of their work and what it means to complete it successfully.
Students should be encouraged to bear in mind the aims of their work and to assess their own progress to meet these aims as they proceed. They will then be able to guide their own work and so become independent learners.
I think this is something that I can improve on. I give a lot of verbal feedback daily, and then a lot of individual written feedback when looking at a kid's work (ie. quizzes or homework or projects, depending on the class and the time of year). But, I am not so sure that the kids always have the big picture in mind. So, to that end, to help my 8th-graders frame their minds around what I will be looking for on their semester exam next week in terms of levels of mastery of the learned topics, I've pulled together this hopefully kid-friendly rubric/skills list which I'll go over with the kids prior to the exam. What do you think?? It's a skills list like many of you might have for SBG, but it's sort of hierarchical in terms of ordering what I think are more basic skills and what I think are more complex skills layered on top. Mimicking the MYP scale for "Knowledge and Understanding", the rubric goes up to 8 points in most topics, where a 5 is basically solidly at-grade-level "average" performance, and 7 and 8 are only if you are beginning to approach more advanced topics or skills that are somewhat beyond your grade level.
My goal is that I will go over this rubric with the students this week, and they will self assess which skills they still need to work on over the weekend, so that their efforts are not so randomly scattered during precious review time. In January, after the exams have been graded, they will again self-assess in order to figure out where their skills holes are from the first semester, if any. This type of self-analysis will help them gain independence as a more self-driven learner over time, instead of me always telling them what to work on next and feeling like I fall into the rather unappealing nagging mode.
Sounds like a plan?
Tuesday, December 11, 2012
Review Week
It's so nice to just slow down before the semester test and to review everything we have learned. It's like taking in a deep breath, because finally we are no longer trying to cover as much ground as possible. Finally the kids have come to a reasonable stopping point before THE TEST next week.
So, this week we will "just" do some review in Grades 7 and 8. For that, up my sleeve I have:
this awesome stations review format from Amy Gruen; my normal speed game format (which I may vary up this time to have 3 kids go up at a time to the board, working individually and not keeping team score), and of course mini whiteboards.
Looking forward to the rest of this week! :) There is nothing like fun with review time (coupled with the kids doing extra review problems at home, obviously).
So, this week we will "just" do some review in Grades 7 and 8. For that, up my sleeve I have:
this awesome stations review format from Amy Gruen; my normal speed game format (which I may vary up this time to have 3 kids go up at a time to the board, working individually and not keeping team score), and of course mini whiteboards.
Looking forward to the rest of this week! :) There is nothing like fun with review time (coupled with the kids doing extra review problems at home, obviously).
Saturday, December 8, 2012
11 Recommendations to Middle-ish Grades Math Teachers
Maybe some of these are "radical" and "offensive", or maybe they're not. I'm just throwing them out there. Please don't hate me if you do some of these (I know a couple of them are quite commonly done by many math teachers). These are just my personal opinions, but I feel quite strongly about them. I figured I'd say it here, because some of these things drive me nuts, and I need an outlet.
11. Do not tell a kid to "move things across the equal sign and just change the signs". Preferably you don't ever say this phrase to a kid ever, but if a kid comes to you and says that someone else somewhere (ie. a parent or another teacher) has taught that to them, you need to drill into them the reason why this shortcut works. Grill them until they can articulate why the term necessarily shows up on the other side with the opposite sign.
Reason: If you teach shortcuts like this without the correct foundation of understanding, then down the road the kid cannot approach a complex situation intuitively, because they cannot visualize the equation as a balance.
10. Do not allow your students to do simple equations only in their heads / showing little or no work at the early stages.
Reason: Even if the kid is bright and they can do the equation correctly every time, you are helping them to develop a bad habit that is hard to break. Down the road, when the equations get more complicated and the kid starts to make procedural mistakes, they'll have such a hard time finding their mistakes because they've habitually skipped so many steps.
9. Do not allow your students to "open parentheses" without knowing why they do this and where it is the most useful.
Reason: Normally, it just irks me to see kids do 2(3 - 5 + 1) = 6 - 10 + 2 = -2 instead of following PEMDAS to do 2(3 - 5 + 1) = 2(-1) = -2, but it's really feckin' scary when I see students do
2 (4·5 + 7) = 8 + 10 + 14 = 32 in their second year of algebra. When all the values are known, they don't need to be distributing!!
8. Do not introduce integer operations without explaining the meaning of addition and subtraction of signed numbers! You can use number lines or you can use the idea of counting and neutralizing terms, but in the end, the kids need a framework of understanding.
Reason: I recently tutored a kid on a one-time basis (I was doing a favor for her parent, who's my friend, even though the kid doesn't go to our school), and the kid only knows memorized rules (she rattled them off like a poem), with no conceptual understanding whatsoever when I probed further. Unfortunately, that kind of problem is not really fixable in a day. It can take a teacher weeks to instill the correct habit of thinking. If you teach a kid to memorize a rule for adding or subtracting integers without understanding, then I can almost guarantee you that after the summer they won't remember it. And, if you first teach the rules by memorization, even if you try to explain afterwards the conceptual reasons for the rules, there ain't no one listening.
7. Do not teach "rise over run".
Reason: In my experience, a majority of the concrete-thinking kids out there do not know what the slope means. When you ask them, they just enthusiastically say "rise over run", but they cannot identify it in a table, they cannot find it in a word problem, they certainly cannot say that it's change of y over change of x, and half of them cannot even see it in a graph.
You have other alternatives. I teach slope as "what happens (with the quantity we care about), over how long it takes." For example, the speed of a car is "miles, per hour"; the rate of growth of a plant is "inches, per number of days"; the rate of decrease of savings can be "dollars, per number of weeks". You have alternatives to "rise over run". Learn to teach kids to visualize the coordinate plane as a sort of timeline, where the y-axis describes the interesting values we are observing, and x-axis describes the stages at which those values occur. Once they understand this, then they can correctly pick out the slope given any representation of the function.
6. Do not let any kid in your class get away with saying "A linear function is something that is
y = mx + b."
Reason: Again, in my experience, I can habitually meet a full class of kids who had spent a good part of a previous year learning about lines and linear equations and linear operations, and in the following year when they move to my class and I ask them to tell me simply what is a linear function, the only thing they can say is: Y = mx + b. That is really, really bad. The first thing they should be able to say is that it is a straight line, or that it is a pattern with a constant rate.
Please, please, do teach lines in context. Make sure that kids know what y, m, x, and b all mean in a simple linear situation.
5. Do not introduce sine, cosine, and tangent without explaining their relationship to similar triangles.
Reason: The concept is too abstract, too much of a jump from anything else the kids have done. Give the kids some shadow problems to allow them to see what the ancient mathematicians saw, and why they recorded trigonometric ratios in a chart. Let the 3 ratios arise as an outcome of a natural discovery, a natural need. And then, when you introduce the terms sine, cosine, and tangent, the kids will at least already understand them as sweet nicknames for comparisons between sides.
From then on, whenever you say sin(x) = 0.1283... , remind kids what that means simply by immediately saying, "So the opposite side is about 12.8% as long as the hypotenuse." If you do this consistently, kids will never grow afraid of those ratios.
4. Do not teach right-triangle trigonometry from inside the classroom!
Reason: Kids need to be able to visualize geometry relationships, especially in word problems. Some kids have trouble doing this on a flat sheet of paper. Don't disadvantage those learners. Take them outside, make them build an inclinometer, make them experience angles of elevation, angles of depression, and the idea of measuring heights through triangular ratios. This really only takes a day, or at most two. In the end, when you take them back to the classroom, you will be amazed at how well they can now visualize even complicated word problems involving multiple right triangles.
3. Do distinguish between conceptual and procedural errors. Your modes of intervention should look very different for those two types of mistakes, and what you communicate to the kids as recommended "next steps" should look fairly different as well.
2. Do incorporate writing into your classroom. Writing is an extremely valuable way of learning mathematics. Every project should have a significant writing component. When kids write, they are forced to engage with the subject on a personal level, and so they learn much more.
1. Do make learning fun. From a biological perspective (of primitive survival), our brain makes us remember things permanently when our emotions are triggered. Fun learning isn't a waste of time. It's necessary to help the students build long-term memory!
11. Do not tell a kid to "move things across the equal sign and just change the signs". Preferably you don't ever say this phrase to a kid ever, but if a kid comes to you and says that someone else somewhere (ie. a parent or another teacher) has taught that to them, you need to drill into them the reason why this shortcut works. Grill them until they can articulate why the term necessarily shows up on the other side with the opposite sign.
Reason: If you teach shortcuts like this without the correct foundation of understanding, then down the road the kid cannot approach a complex situation intuitively, because they cannot visualize the equation as a balance.
10. Do not allow your students to do simple equations only in their heads / showing little or no work at the early stages.
Reason: Even if the kid is bright and they can do the equation correctly every time, you are helping them to develop a bad habit that is hard to break. Down the road, when the equations get more complicated and the kid starts to make procedural mistakes, they'll have such a hard time finding their mistakes because they've habitually skipped so many steps.
9. Do not allow your students to "open parentheses" without knowing why they do this and where it is the most useful.
Reason: Normally, it just irks me to see kids do 2(3 - 5 + 1) = 6 - 10 + 2 = -2 instead of following PEMDAS to do 2(3 - 5 + 1) = 2(-1) = -2, but it's really feckin' scary when I see students do
2 (4·5 + 7) = 8 + 10 + 14 = 32 in their second year of algebra. When all the values are known, they don't need to be distributing!!
8. Do not introduce integer operations without explaining the meaning of addition and subtraction of signed numbers! You can use number lines or you can use the idea of counting and neutralizing terms, but in the end, the kids need a framework of understanding.
Reason: I recently tutored a kid on a one-time basis (I was doing a favor for her parent, who's my friend, even though the kid doesn't go to our school), and the kid only knows memorized rules (she rattled them off like a poem), with no conceptual understanding whatsoever when I probed further. Unfortunately, that kind of problem is not really fixable in a day. It can take a teacher weeks to instill the correct habit of thinking. If you teach a kid to memorize a rule for adding or subtracting integers without understanding, then I can almost guarantee you that after the summer they won't remember it. And, if you first teach the rules by memorization, even if you try to explain afterwards the conceptual reasons for the rules, there ain't no one listening.
7. Do not teach "rise over run".
Reason: In my experience, a majority of the concrete-thinking kids out there do not know what the slope means. When you ask them, they just enthusiastically say "rise over run", but they cannot identify it in a table, they cannot find it in a word problem, they certainly cannot say that it's change of y over change of x, and half of them cannot even see it in a graph.
You have other alternatives. I teach slope as "what happens (with the quantity we care about), over how long it takes." For example, the speed of a car is "miles, per hour"; the rate of growth of a plant is "inches, per number of days"; the rate of decrease of savings can be "dollars, per number of weeks". You have alternatives to "rise over run". Learn to teach kids to visualize the coordinate plane as a sort of timeline, where the y-axis describes the interesting values we are observing, and x-axis describes the stages at which those values occur. Once they understand this, then they can correctly pick out the slope given any representation of the function.
6. Do not let any kid in your class get away with saying "A linear function is something that is
y = mx + b."
Reason: Again, in my experience, I can habitually meet a full class of kids who had spent a good part of a previous year learning about lines and linear equations and linear operations, and in the following year when they move to my class and I ask them to tell me simply what is a linear function, the only thing they can say is: Y = mx + b. That is really, really bad. The first thing they should be able to say is that it is a straight line, or that it is a pattern with a constant rate.
Please, please, do teach lines in context. Make sure that kids know what y, m, x, and b all mean in a simple linear situation.
5. Do not introduce sine, cosine, and tangent without explaining their relationship to similar triangles.
Reason: The concept is too abstract, too much of a jump from anything else the kids have done. Give the kids some shadow problems to allow them to see what the ancient mathematicians saw, and why they recorded trigonometric ratios in a chart. Let the 3 ratios arise as an outcome of a natural discovery, a natural need. And then, when you introduce the terms sine, cosine, and tangent, the kids will at least already understand them as sweet nicknames for comparisons between sides.
From then on, whenever you say sin(x) = 0.1283... , remind kids what that means simply by immediately saying, "So the opposite side is about 12.8% as long as the hypotenuse." If you do this consistently, kids will never grow afraid of those ratios.
4. Do not teach right-triangle trigonometry from inside the classroom!
Reason: Kids need to be able to visualize geometry relationships, especially in word problems. Some kids have trouble doing this on a flat sheet of paper. Don't disadvantage those learners. Take them outside, make them build an inclinometer, make them experience angles of elevation, angles of depression, and the idea of measuring heights through triangular ratios. This really only takes a day, or at most two. In the end, when you take them back to the classroom, you will be amazed at how well they can now visualize even complicated word problems involving multiple right triangles.
3. Do distinguish between conceptual and procedural errors. Your modes of intervention should look very different for those two types of mistakes, and what you communicate to the kids as recommended "next steps" should look fairly different as well.
2. Do incorporate writing into your classroom. Writing is an extremely valuable way of learning mathematics. Every project should have a significant writing component. When kids write, they are forced to engage with the subject on a personal level, and so they learn much more.
1. Do make learning fun. From a biological perspective (of primitive survival), our brain makes us remember things permanently when our emotions are triggered. Fun learning isn't a waste of time. It's necessary to help the students build long-term memory!
Ich versuche in Deutsch schreiben...
Meine Deutscheskurse A2 ist gerade fertig! Die naechste Stufe beginnt im Februar. Ich glaube dass, ich meisten einfache Sachen verstehe, aber natuerlich ich muss mehr ueben. Es gibt etwas Worten an den ich kann nie mich erinnere. Und die Regeln und die Praepositionen sind auch (mehr als) ein Bisschen schwer... Aber Deutsch ist immer viel Spass zu lernen. :) Im Dezember und im Januar will ich selbstaendig studieren, um besser im Februar zu sein. Damit ich mehr angenehm mit den Regeln bin, ich moechte jede Woche ein Bisschen in Deutsch schreiben. So! Hier ist meine erste Ubung. Wenn Sie gut Deutsch sprechen, koennen Sie bitte mich korrigieren? Dankeschoen!
Geoff ist weg in den USA, um an einer Messe in Florida teil zu nehmen. Am Sontag fliegt er nach New Jersey um seinen Elterns Haus zu bleiben. Meine Freundin Gabby ist gerade nach San Francisco zurueckgeflogen. (Wir hatten viel Spass, obwohl ich arbeiten musste.) Fur eine Woche (bis Geoffs zurueckflug nach Berlin) habe ich mehr Zeit zu mehr arbeiten... Und ich hoffe dass, wenn Geoff zurueck kommt, alle Arbeit ist schon fertig!! Naechstes Wochenende sind zwei verschiedenen Christmas-Parties, deshalb ich muss einige Rezepten vorbereiten... Ich will einige Deutsche Brataepfel kochen und zu den Parties mitbringen, und vielleicht ich koche auch etwas Anderen...
I find that the German teacher I have is really fantastic, because (in my opinion) she's truly a teacher's teacher. I'll just say that three minutes before the class is scheduled to leave for the evening or to stop for a pause, she'd hand out a worksheet and say, "OK! Let's do one last exercise!" instead of letting us off the hook a few minutes early. And she has some really creative activities to get us to talk more in German class, and I think the class is quite dynamic (over the course of the 3 hours each night, twice a week). And sometimes when I take the train home with her, she still makes me speak German to her the entire time, and she corrects me on the train, too. Really a teacher's teacher! I am so happy that she'll be our teacher all the way through the courses (unless I drop out of the rotation at some point because I get too busy). My German still sucks, but it is through no fault of hers. I know that I just need to sit down and get more serious about memorizing and practicing rules, and then I need to find a tandem partner to practice with, in order to get my thinking-while-speaking more up to speed.
Addendum: I find it pretty fun to read back on how my German progress is coming along (however slowly) over time, so I uploaded a sample of my reading of the first paragraph so I can come back and hear myself talking in German at some other point. Here it is if you're curious! It's a little deceptive because obviously it's easier to read something that's been written than to speak off the cuff. Hopefully at some point I can just talk fluidly without having written it down.
Geoff ist weg in den USA, um an einer Messe in Florida teil zu nehmen. Am Sontag fliegt er nach New Jersey um seinen Elterns Haus zu bleiben. Meine Freundin Gabby ist gerade nach San Francisco zurueckgeflogen. (Wir hatten viel Spass, obwohl ich arbeiten musste.) Fur eine Woche (bis Geoffs zurueckflug nach Berlin) habe ich mehr Zeit zu mehr arbeiten... Und ich hoffe dass, wenn Geoff zurueck kommt, alle Arbeit ist schon fertig!! Naechstes Wochenende sind zwei verschiedenen Christmas-Parties, deshalb ich muss einige Rezepten vorbereiten... Ich will einige Deutsche Brataepfel kochen und zu den Parties mitbringen, und vielleicht ich koche auch etwas Anderen...
I find that the German teacher I have is really fantastic, because (in my opinion) she's truly a teacher's teacher. I'll just say that three minutes before the class is scheduled to leave for the evening or to stop for a pause, she'd hand out a worksheet and say, "OK! Let's do one last exercise!" instead of letting us off the hook a few minutes early. And she has some really creative activities to get us to talk more in German class, and I think the class is quite dynamic (over the course of the 3 hours each night, twice a week). And sometimes when I take the train home with her, she still makes me speak German to her the entire time, and she corrects me on the train, too. Really a teacher's teacher! I am so happy that she'll be our teacher all the way through the courses (unless I drop out of the rotation at some point because I get too busy). My German still sucks, but it is through no fault of hers. I know that I just need to sit down and get more serious about memorizing and practicing rules, and then I need to find a tandem partner to practice with, in order to get my thinking-while-speaking more up to speed.
Addendum: I find it pretty fun to read back on how my German progress is coming along (however slowly) over time, so I uploaded a sample of my reading of the first paragraph so I can come back and hear myself talking in German at some other point. Here it is if you're curious! It's a little deceptive because obviously it's easier to read something that's been written than to speak off the cuff. Hopefully at some point I can just talk fluidly without having written it down.
Friday, December 7, 2012
Weeks Before Vacation
So, it's nearing Christmas at the end of a long term of school (the last time we had any day off was in early October). In my "weak" Grade 9 group, kids are starting to lose some of their focus. In my mind, I know that they probably cannot help it, because even I am looking forward to vacation. But well, this is the kind of teacher I am. I said this very calmly and firmly to the 9th-graders in the last 10 minutes of class (after they had been idly, overly casually doing work for about 30 minutes):
"Alright, listen. You guys are dismissed today to go to lunch when you have shown me that your worksheet is complete and that everything is correct. ...No, don't complain. You know, I used to do this a lot at my last school, and those kids used to complain to me all the time about being dismissed late, but then the next year those same kids would write me emails to THANK me for teaching them so much math. So, I'll just tell you in advance: 'You are welcome!!'"
The half of the class that had been on task, laughed at this and packed up on time to go. The other half that had to stay late, mostly finished the worksheets within 5 or so minutes of regular dismissal. Only one kid was mumbling angry comments the whole time (but he gets angry pretty easily and I'm pretty used to it and so I don't take it personally), and then everyone else that had to stay late, actually thanked me on their way out. What sweet kids.
Fun fact: Some of my former students in the Bronx used to call me Yangsta or Yangdizzle. No relation to this story, of course. But these kids definitely don't want to be wasting time in my class, lest the real Yangdizzle come out. *wink*
"Alright, listen. You guys are dismissed today to go to lunch when you have shown me that your worksheet is complete and that everything is correct. ...No, don't complain. You know, I used to do this a lot at my last school, and those kids used to complain to me all the time about being dismissed late, but then the next year those same kids would write me emails to THANK me for teaching them so much math. So, I'll just tell you in advance: 'You are welcome!!'"
The half of the class that had been on task, laughed at this and packed up on time to go. The other half that had to stay late, mostly finished the worksheets within 5 or so minutes of regular dismissal. Only one kid was mumbling angry comments the whole time (but he gets angry pretty easily and I'm pretty used to it and so I don't take it personally), and then everyone else that had to stay late, actually thanked me on their way out. What sweet kids.
Fun fact: Some of my former students in the Bronx used to call me Yangsta or Yangdizzle. No relation to this story, of course. But these kids definitely don't want to be wasting time in my class, lest the real Yangdizzle come out. *wink*
Thursday, December 6, 2012
Proportional Reasoning with Percents
I am a big fan of estimation, probably because I am lazy. I think that most percent problems (obviously not all) can be done with just basic numerical / proportional reasoning.
For example, my Grade 7s are pretty darned good by now at doing something like "find 15% of 6.4". They can articulate that 10% of 6.4 is 0.64, and then half of that is 5% = 0.32, so 15% is 0.64 + 0.32 = 0.96 . They can also do something like "find 12% of 88" by reasoning that 10% is 8.8, and then 1% is 0.88, so 12% is 8.8 + 0.88 + 0.88 = 8.8 + 1.76 = 10.56 . Recently I looked over the big semester test that we had given last year in December, and realized that we won't have time this year before the semester exam to cover enough of proportional reasoning to do a problem like "9 is 15% of what number?" using a setup of proportions and of solving by cross multiplication. (We've only just started proportional reasoning this week.) So, today I just decided to throw up some of those types of questions on the board as the Do Now, and the kids were surprisingly clever at figuring it out! One of them said, "It's not that hard. It's like playing Math Detective."
"3 is 10% of what number?" --> This was the first "backwards" type of question I had put on the board, and the kids thought it was quite easy. You're just multipling by 10 times to get to 100%, which is 30.
"12 is 15% of what number?" --> Some kids naturally, intuitively, broke it down to 5% being 4, which is a "nice" percentage to have/know because then you know that 10% is 8, and therefore 100% is 80.
"6 is 2% of what number?" --> To do this, they were also clever. Some did it as 1% is 3, so 100% must be 300 if you know that one out of the 100 parts is 3. One kid immediately thought that you can scale both values up by 50 times in order to reach 100%, to save us from doing two steps of work.
I really liked these discussions, because I think -- in lack of a formal proportional setup -- this is the most intuitive way of approaching percentages, in my mind. It reinforces the meaning of percents and frees kids from fear of these fairly basic everyday concepts.
We discussed briefly why this is proportional reasoning. It tied very nicely to the word problems we did today on proportions, but I am not going to touch cross multiplication until January. (It's just too much, too soon for many of them, and they have already worked very hard to fill in the gaps this semester.)
So, go seventh-graders! I feel very hopeful that, despite my concerns about many of them at the start of the year, the majority of the class is nearly caught up to where they ought to be at this time of the year.
For example, my Grade 7s are pretty darned good by now at doing something like "find 15% of 6.4". They can articulate that 10% of 6.4 is 0.64, and then half of that is 5% = 0.32, so 15% is 0.64 + 0.32 = 0.96 . They can also do something like "find 12% of 88" by reasoning that 10% is 8.8, and then 1% is 0.88, so 12% is 8.8 + 0.88 + 0.88 = 8.8 + 1.76 = 10.56 . Recently I looked over the big semester test that we had given last year in December, and realized that we won't have time this year before the semester exam to cover enough of proportional reasoning to do a problem like "9 is 15% of what number?" using a setup of proportions and of solving by cross multiplication. (We've only just started proportional reasoning this week.) So, today I just decided to throw up some of those types of questions on the board as the Do Now, and the kids were surprisingly clever at figuring it out! One of them said, "It's not that hard. It's like playing Math Detective."
"3 is 10% of what number?" --> This was the first "backwards" type of question I had put on the board, and the kids thought it was quite easy. You're just multipling by 10 times to get to 100%, which is 30.
"12 is 15% of what number?" --> Some kids naturally, intuitively, broke it down to 5% being 4, which is a "nice" percentage to have/know because then you know that 10% is 8, and therefore 100% is 80.
"6 is 2% of what number?" --> To do this, they were also clever. Some did it as 1% is 3, so 100% must be 300 if you know that one out of the 100 parts is 3. One kid immediately thought that you can scale both values up by 50 times in order to reach 100%, to save us from doing two steps of work.
I really liked these discussions, because I think -- in lack of a formal proportional setup -- this is the most intuitive way of approaching percentages, in my mind. It reinforces the meaning of percents and frees kids from fear of these fairly basic everyday concepts.
We discussed briefly why this is proportional reasoning. It tied very nicely to the word problems we did today on proportions, but I am not going to touch cross multiplication until January. (It's just too much, too soon for many of them, and they have already worked very hard to fill in the gaps this semester.)
So, go seventh-graders! I feel very hopeful that, despite my concerns about many of them at the start of the year, the majority of the class is nearly caught up to where they ought to be at this time of the year.
Saturday, December 1, 2012
Thinking About Elementary Math
Recently I've had some questions come my way about what the younger kids need to be able to do in order to be successful in the future years. I am no expert, but I am very interested in getting a discussion started about this from a Middle School perspective.
Specifically:
Specifically:
- I think in grades 1 - 4, the most important skills to develop are obviously basic (up to two-digit) addition, subtraction, and "nice" multiplication and division using the times table. For the young kids, manipulatives are very important in order for them to understand the meaning of these operations.
- In Germany (and probably other places as well), they use a triangular diagram to teach the idea of inverse operations in elementary school. For example, the diagram below reinforces that 60, the total, can be divided by 5 to get 12, or divided by 12 to get 5. The two bottom operations multiply to form 60. The neat thing about this triangle is that it extends into algebraic relationships such as D = rt, D/r = t, or D/t = r. My lawyer friend who grew up in Israel told me that this is how they learned basic operations in school.
- I think that by grade 5, kids should be able to do addition from left to right, in order to build up their estimation skills. For example, adding 638 + 290, yo can look from left to right to get 800... And then when you look just one digit ahead, you can already estimate that 9+3 is bigger than 10, so the result is actually 900 something. 928, to be exact, if you keep adding from left to right, peeking just one digit ahead each time. The nice about this is that even if kids only quickly looked at two numbers being added, they can already estimate the sum reasonably.
- I think that by grade 5, kids should be able to multiplication of two-digit by one-digit numbers in their heads. Teaching kids to break down (82 times 6) into 80 times 6, plus 2 times 6, reinforces two things: placement values and the idea of distributive property within arithmetic. It makes introducing the algebraic distributive property in middle-school a breeze, if kids already have seen it in action.
- Sometime in grade 5 or grade 6, when kids start to learn conversion from decimals into fractions, this should be done using their proper naming of numbers. 5.6 is read properly as "five and six-tenths", and the way we write that in fractions is immediately 5 6/10. Going backwards, they should be able to do the same, at least for base-ten fractions. 3 9/100, is read as "three and nine-hundredths", which writes as 3.09 in decimals.
- There are a lot of resources out there for fractions already, but I think that the most important representation is the number line and the comparison of numbers. To find a fraction of any number, the kids need to know that 1/n is one out of n equal pieces, so k/n just means that size, multiplied by k. I think the concept behind fractions is so so so SO important, so it should always be done in context.
- Dividing by simple fractions can be done similarly using reasoning. I teach my middle-schoolers how to intuitively divide 5 by 1/3 by first asking them what is 1 divided by 1/3. We draw diagrams until everyone can see why it is 3 (and I use language like, "how many times does 1/3 fit into 1?"). And then I ask them what is 5 divided by 1/3. ("How many times does 1/3 fit into 5?") The language that you use with fractions, I think, has an immediate impact on the children's understanding of the operations. Of course, this does not bypass the need to show them the manipulation of fractions in division, but it helps to add meaning to the otherwise rote/abstract operations.
- By the way, the triangle (shown above) can be used to reinforce why 5 divided by 1/3 is 15, and why 5 divided by 15 is 1/3. One of Geoff's friends has a good analogy to cutting potatoes in order to illustrate this. (You can cut 5 potatoes into 15 groups of 1/3 potatoes each, or if you already knew that you wanted to make 1/3 potatoes the size of each group, you can make 15 groups.)
- I recently wrote a short email outlining my recommendations for decimal division in Grade 6, so I'll just paste it here. "I think
for decimal division, kids should be able to reason through
step-by-step, starting with normal division. For example, to teach
7.2/6, I’d start first
with 72/6 = 12, and then ask kids what they think 7.2/6 will be, and
then ask them what 7.2/0.6 will be, and then 7.2/0.06, etc. You can use
it to introduce this idea of ratios between numbers. Have them practice
this on other decimal pairs instead of teaching
the rote “moving it over this many times” trick.
Also, this is a useful trick: 700000/35000 = 700/35 = 20. Or 840/120 = 84/12 = 42/6 = 7. They should always reduce before division, if they can. It’ll make their lives much, much easier down the road to not have to divide with so many digits involved.Another thing is that, I don’t know how familiar the Grade 6 kids already are with fractions, but I think that if the division is very messy, the kids should stop after the unit digit and just write the rest as a fraction. The most important thing from Grade 7 on is that they can estimate decimals, such as to know that 11/7 is between 1 and 2, just past 1.5 because 11/7 = 1 4/7. They don’t need to really get that it is 1.57142857142857142857142857142857 since we all have calculators…."What do you think? Disagreements? Something I missed? I would love to hear what all the MS teachers have to say about what makes a child successful coming into MS.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)